Experts Unraveled The Mystery Of A Lost WWII Submarine – And Its 80 Vanished Crew Members

Experts Unraveled The Mystery Of A Lost WWII Submarine – And Its 80 Vanished Crew Members

Tim Taylor and his team are looking for a U.S. submarine that disappeared in mysterious circumstances. The sub vanished without a trace 75 years ago – with 80 sailors on board. Nobody has heard from them since… and nobody has any idea what happened to the missing craft. So Taylor is hyped to try to solve the decades-old mystery. But then his underwater vehicle develops a fault. Frustrated, Taylor brings the craft back to the surface with a heavy heart. He takes a glance at the data it’s recorded, not expecting to find much. Then he spots two strange inconsistencies. And what the technology has finally unearthed is enough to make the hairs on your arms stand on end.

U.S.S. Grayback

The sub the researchers were searching for is the U.S.S. Grayback. Or, as it was less lyrically known, the S.S.-208. This salvage operation was carried out on behalf of the Lost 52 Project, which is dedicated to locating the 52 U.S. submarines that disappeared in WWII. That’s right: the U.S. Navy had posted the Grayback as missing in late March 1944, over 75 years ago. And little is known about the sub’s mysterious disappearance.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Grayback_(SS208)._Port_side,_05-06-1941_-_NARA_-_513040.tif

The Last Mission

Here are the facts. On January 28, 1944, the Grayback embarked on a combat patrol from Pearl Harbor. It was her tenth mission – and, as it happens, it would be her final one. The sub sent a message back to base on February 24, reporting that she’d sunk the Japanese freighters Toshin Maru and Taikei Maru and hit two others. But that wasn’t the last anybody heard from her.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/aerial-photograph-of-pearl-harbor-honolulu-hawaii-before-news-photo/615315518?adppopup=true

Two Torpedoes Left

The sub made another report on February 25. Her crew said the craft had done serious damage to the liner Asama Maru – a Japanese troop carrier – and sunk the tanker Nanpo Maru. But these attacks over two days had left the Grayback with just two torpedoes. So she had to set sail to Midway Atoll in the North Pacific for resupply. Yet the craft never arrived.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/jimmy-carter-moored-in-the-magnetic-silencing-royalty-free-image/181827263?adppopup=true

Last Message

That February 25 radio message was the last anyone heard from the Grayback. Navy commanders had anticipated that the submarine would dock at Midway Atoll on March 7, 1944 – but there was no sign of her on that date. Even more alarmingly, the Grayback still hadn’t appeared three weeks later. So the authorities had no choice but to declare her and her crew of 80 as lost at sea. They did this on March 30. Still the question remained: what had happened to the Grayback?

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/men-at-a-royal-air-force-training-centre-1941-men-at-a-news-photo/102729702?adppopup=true

Simply Vanished

Dozens of men had seemingly perished, leaving their devastated loved ones looking for answers. But there was simply no trace of the submarine that had proved to be a huge asset to the U.S. Navy. And make no mistake about it: the Grayback and her crew had played their part in many WWII battles. That’s perhaps not surprising when you consider the craft was built at the legendary Groton, Connecticut’s Electric Boat Company.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/the-united-states-navys-newest-attack-submarine-the-uss-news-photo/517243882?adppopup=true

Best Submarines In The World

The skilled Electric Boat Company workers had been building submarines since 1899. In fact, they had built the U.S. Navy’s very first submarine: the U.S.S. Holland. And at the time of WWI, Electric Boat Company and associated shipyards built 85 submarines, among other craft, for both the U.S. Navy and the British Royal Navy. Then, during WWII, Electric Boat created another 74 submarines – including the Grayback.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/1940s-launch-of-submarine-uss-gato-ss-212-august-15-1941-at-news-photo/1135991766?adppopup=true

One Of Twelve

The Grayback was a Tambor-class vessel, of which 12 were built. Seven examples were then destroyed during the war, and Tambor submarines were ultimately taken out of combat service in 1945. The Grayback, of course, was one of those subs that never made it to the end of the conflict.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Usstambor.jpg

Tough As Nails

The size of the Grayback makes this pretty improbable, too. When she was finally completed, she was a little over 300 feet from stem to stern and displaced 2,410 tons when submerged. At her widest point, she measured just over 27 feet, while her maximum surface speed was around 20 knots. Underwater, she could travel at just under nine knots. At a lower speed, the sub could also stay submerged for up to 48 hours, and her range was nearly over 12,500 miles. So it would take a lot to bring her down.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/submarine-patrolling-in-the-pacific-news-photo/615308250?adppopup=true

A Powerhouse

It was powerful, too. The Grayback’s two propellers were driven by four electric motors, charged by a quartet of diesel engines. Her official crew strength was 54 enlisted men and six officers. But as we know, she had 80 men aboard when she disappeared in 1944. And that’s not all.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/sailor-on-the-bridge-of-a-u-s-submarine-in-port-at-new-news-photo/615306888?adppopup=true

Armed To The Teeth

The Grayback was well-equipped, with ten 21-inch torpedo tubes – six set towards the bow and four at the stern. Further armament came in the form of a 50-caliber machine gun and Bofors 40mm and Oerlikon 20mm cannons. These weapons were intended as defense against assault from the air, although they could also be used in attacks on enemy shipping when the sub was surfaced. But they couldn’t prevent the craft’s ultimate fate.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Grayback_(SSG-574)_building.jpg

Off To A Good Start

Some ten months after the Electric Boat Company had started her construction, the Grayback was launched on January 31, 1941, by Rear Admiral Wilson Brown’s wife. The submarine was commissioned into the U.S. Navy on June 30 – only five months or so before America became embroiled in WWII. And things started well enough.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/navy-submarine-royalty-free-image/152183057?adppopup=true

Testing Her Capabilities

After her commissioning, the Grayback embarked on her shakedown cruise under the command of Lieutenant Willard A. Saunders on Long Island Sound. This was an opportunity to test out the submarine’s systems and to allow the crew to familiarize themselves with the vessel. And with the sub standing up to the task, she finally went on patrol to Chesapeake Bay and the Caribbean in September 1941. Then Pearl Harbor happened.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/conning-tower-of-u-s-submarine-august-1943-location-news-photo/615308206?adppopup=true

Cruising The Pacific

After further maintenance at Portsmouth Naval Shipyard on the Maine coast, the Grayback headed for Pearl Harbor in February 1942 – as the U.S. was decidedly now a part of the conflict. And things were about to get serious for the boat and her crew. On February 15, the submarine set off on her first wartime patrol. She sailed into the Pacific and cruised along the coasts of the island of Guam, which Japan had attacked in December 1941.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Grayback_(SS_208).jpg

Unable To Return Fire

The Grayback also traveled in proximity to the coast of Saipan, which at that time was similarly Japanese territory. And during this patrol – which lasted three weeks – the boat spent four days in a cat-and-mouse game with a Japanese submarine. The skirmish saw the enemy unleash two torpedoes at the Grayback, and while she emerged unscathed from this assault, she was unable to maneuver into position to return fire.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/the-flak-from-anti-aircraft-fire-can-be-seen-in-the-skies-news-photo/486559313?adppopup=true

Australian Base

After escaping the attentions of the Japanese sub, though, Grayback succeeded in sinking her first ship: a cargo vessel of 3,291 tons. By contrast, the Grayback’s second patrol was a relatively uneventful affair that ended when she docked at Fremantle. This Western Australian port would be her base for most of the rest of her time in service.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Grayback_(SSG-574)_water.jpg

Hitting Ship Number Two

The Grayback’s next two patrols in the South China Sea were blighted by Axis patrol boats, moonlit nights and seas that were difficult to navigate. Nevertheless, she managed to hit an enemy sub and some merchant ships during these spells in the ocean. Then her fifth tour of duty began on December 7, 1942, when she set off from Australia.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/aircraft-attacks-two-german-submarines-caught-on-the-news-photo/615316012?adppopup=true

Christmas Day Jackpot

On Christmas Day 1942, the Grayback surfaced, catching four landing barges unaware and proceeding to sink them all. Then, four days later, an enemy sub fired torpedoes at the American craft, although the Grayback’s crew took successful evasive action. The start of 1943 was similarly eventful, as the U.S. sub attacked the Imperial Japanese Navy vessel I-18. And while the I-18 ultimately escaped undamaged this time around, the destroyer U.S.S. Fletcher sank the Japanese boat with depth charges the following month. All her 102 crewmen perished as a consequence.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Fletcher_(DD-445)_underway_at_sea,_circa_the_1960s_(NH_68912).jpg

Rescue Op

During this fifth tour, moreover, the Grayback carried out a daring rescue operation. Six Americans who had been aboard a wrecked Martin B-26 Marauder bomber were stranded at Munda Bay on the Solomon Islands. Two of the submarine’s men went ashore after dark and found the airmen, while the Grayback went on to dive at dawn to escape the attentions of Japanese planes.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Closeup_view_of_Martin_B-26C_in_flight.jpg

Heroic Action

Then, the following night, the two submariners successfully ferried the six survivors back to the Grayback. The boat’s captain, Commander Edward C. Stephan – who had succeeded Saunders in September 1942 – won the Navy Cross for this action along with a U.S. Army Silver Star. Continuing on her mission, the submarine later torpedoed several Japanese craft, although she was ultimately damaged herself by depth charges dropped from an enemy destroyer.

Photo by The Montifraulo Collection/Getty Images

Back To Brisbane

The weapons had damaged a hatch on the Grayback’s hull, and the resulting leakage forced her to return to port in Brisbane, Australia. And, unfortunately, the submarine’s next patrol in February 1943 saw no successful attacks – owing in part to a newly fitted but malfunctioning radar. In any case, the Grayback managed to survive to her seventh tour, which began from Brisbane on April 25, 1943.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/as-a-pool-of-foam-from-a-near-miss-spreads-out-smoke-rises-news-photo/3088805?adppopup=true

Multiple Triumphs

On this cruise, the Grayback came across a Japanese convoy and hit the merchant ship Yodogawa Maru with two torpedoes, sinking her. Then, a few days later, the U.S. vessel torpedoed an enemy destroyer, causing extensive damage. Nor was that the last of the American victories; the following day, the Grayback sank yet another cargo ship, the England Maru, and hit two more. Following these triumphs, then, it was time to sail back to Pearl Harbor and on to San Francisco, California, for a refit.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Grayback_(SSG-574)_building_attack.jpg

Pacific Destination

On September 12, 1943, the Grayback was back at Pearl Harbor and ready for another Pacific mission – her eighth of the war – with Commander John Anderson Moore now in charge of the boat. And so two weeks after returning to Pearl Harbor, the submarine set off for Midway Atoll alongside the U.S.S. Shad.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Shad;0823504.jpg

Forming A Wolfpack

At Midway Atoll, the Grayback and the Shad were joined by the U.S.S. Cero, with the three vessels constituting what was known as a “wolfpack.” This approach of combining submarines as joint attack forces had proved highly successful when used by German U-boats, although it was the first time that the U.S. Navy had tried the tactic.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Cero_(SS-225).jpg

Hunting For Prey

The new stratagem proved to be effective, however. Between them, the three subs accounted for the sinking of 38,000 tons of Japanese shipping and damage to a further 3,300 tons. Having used up all their torpedoes, the trio then turned back to Midway Atoll, arriving there on November 10, 1943. And after the success of this mission, Moore became the second of the Grayback’s skippers to win a Navy Cross.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/young-naval-ratings-on-a-british-submarine-during-world-war-news-photo/3364226?adppopup=true

Earning A Navy Cross

Then, on December 2, 1943, the Grayback set off again from Pearl Harbor for the East China Sea. During this ninth patrol, the submarine fired the entirety of her torpedo supply in five days of attacks, sinking four Japanese ships in the process before returning once again to Pearl Harbor. Commander Moore’s exploits on that tour earned him another Navy Cross.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/german-submarine-receiving-a-direct-hit-from-an-american-news-photo/3275424?adppopup=true

Final Active Service

Finally, after stopping off in Pearl Harbor for just over three weeks, the Grayback set sail for her tenth – and, as it turned out, her last – active service mission on January 28, 1944. And as we learned earlier, her last radio contact with base came on February 25. After that, nothing more was ever heard from the submarine, leading the Navy to duly declare her lost on March 30.

Richard Damm / YouTube

Big Time Targets

On that final mission, the Grayback had singlehandedly sunk a staggering 21,594 tons of Japanese shipping craft. It had been the third such trip she’d sailed on with Moore at the helm, and the commander was posthumously handed a third Navy Cross for his achievements at sea. The Grayback herself was also ultimately awarded eight battle stars for her WWII service.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/view-of-the-aftermath-of-the-sinking-of-a-japanese-merchant-news-photo/586866819?adppopup=true

Undisclosed Location

It would be many decades, though, before anyone found out exactly what had happened to the Grayback and her 80-strong crew. Initially, the U.S. Navy believed that she had sunk beneath the waves at around 100 miles to the southeast of the Japanese island of Okinawa. Yet as it was later discovered, this assumption was based on data that included a crucial error.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/submarine-uss-stickleback-18-may-1952-jack-shumaker-eddie-news-photo/1048255406?adppopup=true

Translation Error

The information that the Navy had relied upon, you see, came from records that had been kept by the Japanese. As it turned out, though, a single digit in a map reference had been wrongly transcribed when the relevant document was being translated. Consequently, the Grayback was actually far from the location that had been assumed over the years.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/submarine-uss-stickleback-18-may-1952-jack-shumaker-eddie-news-photo/1048255418?adppopup=true

Revisiting The Records

And it wasn’t until 2018, when American Tim Taylor decided to re-examine the case of the Grayback’s disappearance, that the mystery was untangled. Taylor is the founder of the Lost 52 Project – a private enterprise working to find the remains of the 52 submarines that disappeared without trace during the Second World War.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/submarine-wreck-royalty-free-image/1183621148?adppopup=true

Starting From A Success

We’ll come back shortly to the results of Taylor’s reinvestigation of the Grayback mystery, but first we’ll focus on him and his organization. The Lost 52 Project started after a successful search for the U.S. submarine R-12, which had been lost in 1943 along with 42 of her crew. Also known as the SS-89, the vessel sank during a training exercise off the coast of Florida.

https://twitter.com/USSBowfin/status/1175820558468079624/photo/1

Complete Overhaul

Launched in 1919, the U.S.S. R-12 was something of a veteran, as she had actually been decommissioned from the U.S. Navy in 1932 and assigned to the reserve fleet. With war threatening, however, the Navy brought her back into service in July 1940. The R-12 then sailed to Naval Submarine Base New London at Groton, Connecticut, where she underwent a comprehensive overhaul.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Naval_Submarine_Base_New_London_aerial_photo_c1968.jpg

Patrolling Panama

So, in October 1940 the R-12 was ready for active duty, with her first mission being to patrol the waters around the Panama Canal. A year later, the Navy ordered the submarine to return to New London, from where she cruised along the shores of New England. And after the Pearl Harbor attack in December 1941, the R-12 returned to the Panama Canal, where she spent the following ten months.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/panama-canal-bridge-sunrise-royalty-free-image/516368294

Training Vessel

After nearly a year in Panama, the R-12 then went on various cruises until May 1943, when she was reassigned as a training submarine based at Key West, Florida. The following month, however, she was sailing on an exercise when a forward section of the vessel began to take on water. And in mere seconds, the submarine was overwhelmed, leading her to sink to a depth of 600 feet.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/nuclear-submarine-under-the-wave-royalty-free-image/947265168

Unexplained And Undiscovered

As the R-12 began to plunge below the waves, five of her crew who had been above deck on the conning tower – including skipper Lieutenant Commander E. E. Shelby – were thrown overboard into the sea. They were the only survivors of the catastrophic sinking, as the remaining 42 crew members all lost their lives. The cause of the accident was never fully explained, and the wreck remained undiscovered for nearly seven decades.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/the-k-549-borei-a-class-nuclear-powered-ballistic-missile-news-photo/1224537067?adppopup=true

Rediscovering The Past

But in fall 2010 Taylor and his crew aboard Research Vessel Tiburon discovered the remains of the R-12 using a high-tech remotely controlled robot. The team also went on to revisit the area on further expeditions, mapping the site and taking images of the wreck. In addition, they made every effort to contact surviving relatives of the submariners who had died in the accident.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/robot-inspects-a-sunken-ship-deep-under-water-royalty-free-image/873965514

Founding The Lost 52

And it was that successful hunt for the wreck of the R-12 that prompted Taylor to found the Lost 52 Project. The organization takes its name from the fact that 52 submarines were sunk without a trace during World War II. These tragedies had an extremely high human cost, too, with 3,505 submariners perishing in total.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/the-bearded-gun-crew-of-the-u-s-submarine-old-betsy-man-a-news-photo/3206218?adppopup=true

Tough, But Not Impossible

All in all, then, the Lost 52 Project aims to discover the location of all of the U.S. Navy submarines sunk during the war. It’s a tall order, but over the past decade Taylor and his crews have come across five submarines whose precise whereabouts were previously unknown. And their mission goes much further than that, too.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Naval_photograph_documenting_the_Japanese_attack_on_Pearl_Harbor,_Hawaii_which_initiated_US_participation_in_World…_-_NARA_-_295977.jpg

Surveying The Ocean

In particular, Taylor wants to both uncover the fates of these sunken subs for posterity and, crucially, to give family members of the lost seamen some closure. And along with locating the craft, Lost 52 works to create comprehensive surveys of the wreckage found, collects artifacts and makes material available for educational purposes.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWs4BXS5P0I&feature=emb_logo

The Project Is Working

What’s more, the Lost 52 Project has discovered two other WWII submarines alongside the R-12 and the Grayback. The U.S.S. Grunion was found off the coast of Alaska, while the U.S.S. S-28 was located in Hawaiian waters. A Cold War-era vessel, the U.S.S. Stickleback, was similarly found off Hawaii. Altogether, then, Taylor and his team’s efforts have been rewarded by notable successes.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USS_Stickleback_(SS-415).jpg

Developments On The Grayback

Now we’ll get back to Taylor’s work on finding the Grayback. On the search for the sub, the ocean explorer got in touch with Japanese researcher Yutaka Iwasaki and asked him to comb through the files of the Sasebo base that had been used by the Japanese Imperial Navy during WWII. The records there included daily radio updates from Naha on Okinawa Island, which had been the site of a Japanese naval air facility.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/rear-admiral-forrest-sherman-looks-on-as-us-fleet-admiral-news-photo/2695689?adppopup=true

Decoding The Messages

So, Iwasaki duly got to work, upon which he spotted the crucial single-digit error. This mistake had been made in the transcribed version of a report that had been radioed into Sasebo from Naha on February 27, 1944 – just a couple of days after the Grayback had reported back to base for the last time. And the relevant Japanese message detailed an attack by a Nakajima B5N bomber that had taken off from an aircraft carrier.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/radio-operators-await-signals-of-distress-on-board-a-news-photo/3137255?adppopup=true

Submarine Bomber

The Nakajima B5N was a Japanese torpedo bomber, and this particular example flying on February 27 had apparently discharged a 500-pound bomb onto a submarine traveling above the waves. The report also described how the device had hit the sub just to the rear of the conning tower. Then, after that, the vessel had blown up and quickly sunk with no apparent survivors.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/photo/nuclear-submarine-at-northern-waters-royalty-free-image/518223874?adppopup=true

Unearthing The Location

And while speaking to The New York Times in November 2019, Iwasaki described what he had found in the Japanese wartime files. “In that radio record, there [are] a longitude and a latitude of the attack, very clearly,” he explained. Astonishingly, though, these coordinates marked a location that was more than 100 miles distant from the one the U.S. Navy had assumed to be correct since 1949.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nakajima_B5N2_green.jpg

Location At Last

So, armed with this new, accurate information, Taylor felt that there was now a realistic chance of locating the wreck of the Grayback. And, amazingly, the Lost 52 Project team did indeed find the lost submarine, whose hull was almost entirely in one piece even after several decades had passed. Yet this discovery was a cause for mixed emotions among the divers and researchers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubNbxbwFb1c&t=8s

A Sobering Event

Speaking to The New York Times, Taylor recalled the feelings of the Lost 52 team. “We were elated. But it’s also sobering because we just found 80 men,” he said. And, of course, there were others for whom this discovery was a momentous event. They were the relatives of the submariners who had lost their lives aboard the Grayback.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubNbxbwFb1c&t=8s

Known Only To God

One of the people greatly affected by the news that the Grayback’s remains had been discovered was Gloria Hurney, whose uncle Raymond Parks had served aboard the submarine as an electrician’s mate, first class. In November 2019 she told ABC News, “There’s a book I read, and it says these ships are known only to God. But now we know where the Grayback is.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubNbxbwFb1c&t=8s

Shock And Grief

Hurney also spoke to CNN that same month, telling a reporter, “The discovery brings closure to the questions that surrounded the Grayback as far as its sinking and location. I believe it will allow healing as relatives of crew members come together to share their stories.” Hurney added that upon first hearing about the discovery, she had felt shock and grief. But later on, the news had brought peace and comfort.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Bod4PLoHrc

Committed To Finding Him

Kathy Taylor is another relative of one of those who lost their lives aboard the Grayback, as John Patrick King – who served as an electrician’s mate, third class – had been both her uncle and godfather. And while speaking to ABC News, she paid touching tribute to the late veteran, saying, “I committed from the very beginning, from a little girl, that I was gonna find him or follow him or keep his memory alive – whatever I could do.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubNbxbwFb1c&t=8s